In modern web development, using the <dialog> element as a modal without using showModal() is possible, but it requires some additional JavaScript to achieve the desired behavior. The showModal() method is the standard way to display a <dialog> element as a modal, but if you want to explore other options, you can use the following approach:

  1. Using JavaScript and CSS: You can use JavaScript and CSS to show and hide the <dialog> element as a modal.


    <button id="openModalButton">Open Modal</button> <dialog id="myDialog"> <p>This is a modal dialog.</p> <button id="closeModalButton">Close</button> </dialog>


    const openModalButton = document.getElementById('openModalButton'); const closeModalButton = document.getElementById('closeModalButton'); const myDialog = document.getElementById('myDialog'); openModalButton.addEventListener('click', () => { = 'block'; }); closeModalButton.addEventListener('click', () => { = 'none'; });


    dialog { display: none; }

    In this example, the dialog is initially hidden (display: none), and when the "Open Modal" button is clicked, the display property of the dialog is set to block, making it visible. When the "Close" button is clicked, the display property is set back to none, hiding the dialog.

    Keep in mind that this approach may lack some of the built-in features that showModal() provides, such as trapping focus inside the dialog, returning focus to the previously focused element, and blocking interactions outside the dialog. If your use case requires these additional features, using showModal() or a third-party modal library is recommended.

  2. Using Third-Party Modal Libraries: If you prefer more advanced features and better accessibility for your modal, you can consider using third-party modal libraries like react-modal, react-bootstrap, or react-modal-dialog. These libraries provide pre-built modal components that handle the modal behavior and accessibility features for you.

    Here's an example of using react-modal:

    npm install react-modal

    JavaScript (React):

    import React, { useState } from 'react'; import Modal from 'react-modal'; function App() { const [isModalOpen, setIsModalOpen] = useState(false); return ( <div> <button onClick={() => setIsModalOpen(true)}>Open Modal</button> <Modal isOpen={isModalOpen} onRequestClose={() => setIsModalOpen(false)} contentLabel="My Modal" > <p>This is a modal dialog.</p> <button onClick={() => setIsModalOpen(false)}>Close</button> </Modal> </div> ); }

    The react-modal library handles the modal behavior, accessibility, and focus trapping for you, making it a more comprehensive solution compared to manually using the <dialog> element. Similar third-party libraries are available for other JavaScript frameworks as well.

Keep in mind that using the <dialog> element directly or custom approaches may not provide the same level of accessibility and user experience as dedicated modal libraries. Therefore, it's essential to consider your project's requirements and use the appropriate approach accordingly.

Have questions or queries?
Get in Touch